India

Calcutta HC Slams Customs Authorities for Judicial Overreach, Relief to Importer in 27-Year-Old ‘Prawn Feed’ Classification Dispute [Read Order]

Posted on by Minakshi






Calcutta HC Raps Customs in Decades-Long ‘Prawn Feed’ Saga



Calcutta HC Lays Down the Law: Customs Authority Rebuked in 27-Year-Old ‘Prawn Feed’ Case

The Calcutta High Court has delivered a sharp rebuke to customs authorities in a long-standing dispute concerning the classification of imported Artemia cysts. The court’s ruling provides significant relief to an importer embroiled in a legal battle that has spanned nearly three decades.

Decades-Long Dispute Over Artemia Cysts

At the heart of the matter is the classification of Artemia cysts, a crucial element in aquaculture. The importer argued that these cysts should be classified as prawn feed, attracting a lower rate of duty. However, customs officials contested this classification, leading to a protracted legal battle.

The High Court noted with displeasure the significant delay in resolving the issue, highlighting the detrimental impact such delays can have on businesses and the economy.

High Court Upholds Importer’s Claim

The Calcutta High Court has unequivocally directed the Department to accept the classification of Artemia cysts as prawn feed, effectively siding with the importer. The court’s decision is based on a thorough review of the evidence presented and a reaffirmation of established legal principles.

Stern Warning Against Defiance

The court issued a stern warning to the customs authorities, emphasizing the importance of adhering to court orders and avoiding unnecessary delays in resolving disputes. The HC stated that the deliberate defiance and delay has cost the importer dearly and wasted judicial resources.

Summary:

  • Calcutta HC directs Customs to classify Artemia cysts as prawn feed.
  • Court rebukes authorities for 27-year delay in resolving the dispute.
  • A strong warning was issued against defying court orders and causing undue delays.
Key Takeaways:

  • The ruling provides clarity on the classification of Artemia cysts, potentially impacting the aquaculture industry.
  • The High Court’s stance sends a strong message against bureaucratic delays and non-compliance with judicial directives.
  • Businesses should benefit from the court’s emphasis on swift and fair resolution of trade-related disputes.
  • This case highlights the challenges importers face in navigating complex customs regulations in India.